Study | Study duration | Treatment | Dosage | Total n | Success | Defaecation rate |
Thomson et al12 | 2-Week crossover | PEG 3350+E | Mean 0.6–0.7 g/kg/day | 51 | 83% | 3.12 per week |
Placebo | N/A | 51 | 21% | 1.45 per week, p<0.001 | ||
Candy et al13 | 12 Weeks | PEG 3350+E | Mean 11.8 g/day | 28 | – | 9.4 per week |
Lactulose | Mean 24.1 g/day | 30 | – | 7.9 per week, p = 0.007 | ||
Dupont et al14 | 12 Weeks | PEG 4000 | 4–8 g/day±enemas | 51 | – | 8.5/7 per week |
Lactulose | 3.33–6.66 g/day±enemas | 45 | – | 11.5/6 per week, p = NS (results: toddlers/babies) | ||
Voskuijl et al15 | 8 Weeks | PEG 3350 | Mean dose 5.4 g/day | 50 | 56% | 7.1 per week |
Lactulose | Mean dose 6.7 g/day | 50 | 26%, p = 0.02 | 6.4 per week, p<0.01 | ||
Gremse et al16 | 2-Week crossover | PEG 3350 | 0.3 g/kg/day | 44 | 84% | 14.8 per 2 weeks |
Lactulose | 1.3 g/kg/day | 44 | 46%, p = 0.002 | 13.5 per 2 weeks | ||
Wang et al17 | 2 Weeks | PEG 4000 | 20 g/day | 105 | 70% | 7 per week (median) |
Lactulose | 10 g/day | 111 | 40%, p<0.05 | 6 per week, p<0.05 | ||
Loening-Baucke et al18 | 12 Months | PEG 3350 | Mean 0.6 g/kg/day | 39 | 62% | 6.8 per week |
Milk of magnesia | Mean 1.2 ml/kg/day | 40 | 43%, p = NS | 8.2 per week, p = NS |
E, electrolytes; NS, not significant; PEG, polyethylene glycol.